Before an Employee Problem Becomes an Employment Problem: What Managers Should Do Early
Updated: 3 days ago
Most employee problems do not begin as major HR cases.
They usually begin with something fairly ordinary.
An employee starts arriving late. Performance slips. A manager receives a complaint. Someone has repeated short-term absence. Two colleagues stop speaking to each other. A previously reliable employee suddenly becomes difficult to manage.
At this stage, many businesses wait. They hope the problem will correct itself. Sometimes it does. Very often, it does not.
The issue grows, positions become entrenched and eventually the business is dealing with a formal grievance, disciplinary process, long-term absence case or potential employment dispute.
The difference between a manageable employee issue and a serious employment problem is often how the situation is handled at the beginning.
Start with the facts
Managers should separate what they know from what they assume.
“Everyone says she has a bad attitude” is not particularly useful. A specific, dated example supported by evidence is very different.
Good HR decisions depend on facts, evidence and specific examples. Before deciding what should happen, establish what has actually happened.
Talk to the employee early
Avoiding the conversation rarely improves the situation.
If performance has dropped, ask why. If attendance has changed, explore what is happening. If behaviour is causing concern, explain clearly what has been observed.
Managers sometimes wait until they are so frustrated that the first meaningful conversation becomes a formal warning. That can make the process unnecessarily confrontational.
A clear conversation at an earlier stage may resolve the problem completely.
Do not decide the outcome first
One of the biggest risks in employee relations is deciding what you want to happen and then creating a process to justify it.
A fair process should genuinely consider the employee’s explanation and the available evidence. That does not mean a business cannot reach a firm decision. It means the decision should come after the facts have been considered.
Check whether something else is going on
Poor performance may be connected to inadequate training. Attendance issues may involve health or caring responsibilities. Behavioural changes may have a wellbeing issue behind them. A conflict between employees may involve allegations that need investigation.
A manager does not have to diagnose every problem. They do need to recognise when there may be more to the situation than appears on the surface.
Be consistent
Employees notice inconsistency very quickly.
If one employee receives a warning for behaviour that another employee has repeatedly been allowed to get away with, the business may struggle to explain the difference later.
Consistency does not mean every case has exactly the same outcome. It means similar situations should be approached using the same principles, and any differences should be capable of explanation.
Keep appropriate records
A common problem arises when a manager says: “We have spoken to them about this loads of times.” But nothing was recorded.
No dates. No examples. No confirmation of what improvement was expected. No evidence that the employee understood there was a concern.
Good records do not need to be unnecessarily bureaucratic. They simply need to show what happened, what was discussed, what was agreed and what happened next.
Know when to get HR involved
Managers should manage. But they should not be expected to navigate every complex employee situation alone.
HR advice is particularly valuable where there is a grievance, discrimination allegation, possible dismissal, long-term sickness, restructuring, redundancy, TUPE, contractual change, disputed facts or the threat of legal action.
Early HR advice can often give the business more options. Once decisions have been communicated or processes have been mishandled, those options may become much narrower.
The objective is not more process
Good HR is not about turning every management problem into paperwork.
It is about helping managers deal with issues fairly, confidently and at the right level.
Sometimes the correct answer is an informal conversation. Sometimes it is a structured improvement plan. Sometimes a formal process is necessary.
The important thing is knowing which approach fits the situation.
Need practical HR support?
If an employee issue is beginning to take up more management time than it should, or you are worried about making the wrong next move, The HFactor can help.
We provide practical HR support for employee relations, performance, absence, grievances, disciplinary matters, restructuring, redundancy, TUPE and organisational change.
Got an HR problem you need to resolve? Start with a free initial consultation at The HFactor: https://www.the-hfactor.com/
Got an HR problem you need to resolve?
Tell us what is happening in your organisation. The HFactor offers a confidential, free initial consultation to help identify your priority HR risks and a practical next step.
Comments