Grievance Raised? Seven Steps to a Fair and Defensible HR Process
A formal grievance is more than an uncomfortable conversation. It is an opportunity to understand a concern, establish facts, protect working relationships and demonstrate that the organisation responds fairly. A rushed process, a manager investigating their own conduct or an unexplained outcome can turn a manageable problem into an entrenched dispute.
For employers in Great Britain, the current Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures provides the framework for a fair approach. Acas also published a revised draft Code in July 2026, but that draft is not yet the operative Code.
1. Acknowledge the concern promptly
When a worker raises a grievance, confirm receipt, explain the relevant procedure and identify the person responsible for progressing it. Avoid promising a particular outcome before hearing the evidence. Check for immediate wellbeing, safeguarding, discrimination or retaliation concerns and consider appropriate interim arrangements.
2. Decide whether informal resolution is suitable
Some misunderstandings can be resolved through an early conversation or mediation, if the people concerned agree and the circumstances permit. But an employee should not be pushed into informal resolution where allegations are serious or they have asked for a formal process. Follow the organisation's grievance policy and take account of the nature of the complaint.
3. Choose a fair decision-maker
Appoint someone sufficiently independent to hear the grievance, and identify who will investigate if fact-finding is required. A manager accused of wrongdoing should not simply decide the complaint about their own conduct. In a small organisation, an external HR professional may help provide appropriate separation of roles.
4. Hold a meeting without unreasonable delay
Arrange the grievance meeting promptly while allowing adequate preparation. Acas suggests ideally within five working days, although circumstances vary. Let the employee explain their concern, provide evidence and say what outcome they seek. Respect the statutory right to be accompanied where it applies and consider reasonable adjustments.
5. Investigate proportionately
Review relevant records, interview appropriate witnesses and give those facing allegations a fair opportunity to respond. Keep an open mind. Record what evidence supports or challenges each allegation; do not confuse an allegation with an established fact. Protect confidential information as far as reasonably possible without promising absolute secrecy.
6. Explain the outcome and appeal
Communicate the decision in writing without unreasonable delay. Set out what was considered, the conclusions reached and practical next steps, while respecting other workers' privacy. Explain how to appeal. Wherever possible, arrange for someone not previously involved to hear the appeal impartially.
7. Rebuild confidence after the decision
A grievance outcome is not the end of management's responsibility. Check whether working arrangements, team communication, policies or training should change. Monitor for retaliation and ensure agreed actions are completed. Learn from recurring themes without disclosing personal details unnecessarily.
How The HFactor can help
The HFactor supports employers with grievance and disciplinary investigations, management coaching, policy reviews and complex employee relations cases. We can provide independent support where internal relationships or capacity make impartial handling difficult.
If you need support responding to a grievance or training your managers, request your initial meeting at https://www.the-hfactor.com/.
General information for employers in Great Britain, not legal advice about a particular case.




Comments