Promoted to Manager But Never Trained? The Hidden HR Risk
Updated: 3 days ago
Businesses often promote strong employees into management because they are technically capable, reliable and respected.
The problem is that being good at the job and being good at managing people are not the same skill.
A new manager may understand the work perfectly but still have no experience of handling absence, performance concerns, conflict, grievances, difficult conversations or employee wellbeing.
That gap can create significant HR risk.
The promotion changes the relationship
One of the hardest transitions for a new manager is moving from colleague to manager.
Yesterday, they may have been part of the team. Today, they may have to challenge poor performance, manage attendance or make decisions that colleagues do not like.
That change in relationship is often underestimated.
New managers may avoid difficult conversations because they do not want to upset people. Others may go too far in the opposite direction and become overly formal or rigid because they believe that is what management requires.
Managers need to understand that good management is not about being popular or authoritarian. It is about being clear, fair and consistent.
Performance management requires clarity
A common management mistake is to identify poor performance without being able to explain exactly what is wrong.
A manager should be able to explain what standard is expected, where the employee is falling short, what evidence supports the concern, what improvement is required, what support will be provided and when progress will be reviewed.
Without that structure, performance conversations can quickly feel personal rather than objective.
Absence management needs judgement
Managers are often expected to deal with sickness absence but receive little guidance on how.
Some become too cautious and avoid discussing absence at all. Others focus only on the number of days an employee has been off.
Good absence management requires judgement. Managers should consider whether there is a pattern, whether a health condition or disability may be relevant, whether workload is contributing, whether reasonable adjustments may help and whether medical advice is appropriate.
Difficult conversations are part of management
Avoiding difficult conversations rarely makes them disappear.
Managers need the confidence to raise concerns early, clearly and respectfully. That does not mean immediately starting a formal procedure. Often the right first step is simply a well-managed conversation.
Managers need to understand the importance of evidence
One sentence appears repeatedly in difficult HR cases: “We have spoken to them about this many times.”
Then someone asks when, what was discussed, what was agreed and whether anything was recorded.
Managers do not need to create excessive paperwork, but they should understand the importance of keeping appropriate records.
Grievances need a careful response
A new manager can easily become defensive when an employee raises a grievance, particularly if the grievance concerns the manager themselves.
A grievance should be acknowledged, the concerns clarified and the appropriate process followed. Where the manager is personally involved, someone sufficiently independent may need to handle the matter.
Managers should know when to stop and ask for help
One of the most important management skills is recognising when a situation has moved beyond normal day-to-day management.
HR advice should usually be considered where there is a formal grievance, an allegation of bullying, harassment or discrimination, a potential dismissal, long-term sickness, possible disability or reasonable adjustments, a complex conduct matter, redundancy, restructuring, TUPE, contractual change, threatened legal action or seriously disputed facts.
Managers are not expected to know every answer. They are expected to recognise when the risk is too significant to improvise.
Training does not need to be theoretical
Management development is most useful when it reflects the situations managers actually face.
The objective is not to turn managers into HR professionals. It is to give them enough confidence and structure to manage effectively and involve HR at the right time.
Supporting managers protects the business
Poor management creates HR problems very quickly. But the solution is not simply to blame managers when something goes wrong.
If a business gives someone management responsibility, it also needs to give them the tools to succeed: training, clear policies, access to advice and support when difficult situations arise.
The HFactor provides practical management support, HR guidance and management training for organisations that need experienced HR input without building a full internal HR function.
Have managers who need more confidence dealing with people issues? Start with a free initial consultation at https://www.the-hfactor.com/
Got an HR problem you need to resolve?
Tell us what is happening in your organisation. The HFactor offers a confidential, free initial consultation to help identify your priority HR risks and a practical next step.
Comments