top of page

A grievance may also contain whistleblowing: how managers should respond

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 27
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

A manager receives a complaint about how someone has been treated. Halfway through the email, the employee also describes a practice that could put other people at risk. The subject line says “grievance”, but that may not describe everything requiring attention.


We recommend assessing the substance of a concern before deciding which procedure to use. Employees should not have to identify the correct legal label before managers take the information seriously.


Separate the issues without losing the connection


Whistleblowing protection concerns qualifying disclosures of information about specified wrongdoing, with a reasonable belief that disclosure is in the public interest. A personal grievance is not automatically whistleblowing, although a complaint can involve both.


Acas recommends checking with the person raising a grievance if it appears to contain a whistleblowing disclosure. Employers may need to follow both procedures. We suggest recording the issues requiring assessment and explaining how they will be handled, so nothing disappears between two processes.


Respond to immediate risks


Before planning meetings, consider whether the information indicates an urgent safety or operational concern. Identify who can assess and address that risk without prejudging the allegations.


We recommend preserving relevant records early. Establish what information exists, who holds it and whether routine deletion could remove it. Keep the original concern intact, alongside any later clarification, rather than rewriting it into a summary that becomes the only record.


Choose a credible route for assessment


Consider whether the usual manager is implicated, has already expressed a view or lacks the authority to act. We suggest identifying a suitable person to oversee the response and explaining that person's role.


Agree who will investigate which issues and how overlapping evidence will be handled. A single complaint should not generate contradictory instructions simply because different people are managing different elements. Get advice where the legal classification or the appropriate route is uncertain.


Explain confidentiality carefully


Discuss how information will be handled, who may need to know and any limits on confidentiality. Avoid promises that cannot be kept. Give the person a clear contact for questions and an indication of when they can expect an update.


An update can be useful even when the investigation is still underway. We recommend explaining the stage reached and any change to the expected timetable, while respecting the rights and privacy of others involved.


Check what happens afterwards


Workers making protected disclosures must not suffer detriment because they have done so. We recommend reviewing subsequent management decisions carefully, particularly where changes to duties, access to training or treatment by colleagues could be connected to the concern.


This does not mean ordinary management stops. It means decisions need sound reasons, clear records and appropriate oversight. Deal promptly with any allegation of retaliation rather than waiting for the original investigation to finish.


Prepare managers before the next concern


Acas recommends a whistleblowing policy that explains reporting routes and how the organisation will respond. We suggest testing whether managers can use it with a realistic scenario involving both a personal complaint and a wider concern.


At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations, HR audits and management training. For a initial meeting about your procedures or a sensitive workplace concern, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.


Sources checked 27 October 2026


Acas — Whistleblowing at work: the law:



Acas — Responding to a disclosure:



Acas — Having a policy:



GOV.UK — Whistleblowing:



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page