top of page

A job offer without a signature: what hiring managers need to understand

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 24
2 min read

Updated: Oct 29

The interview goes well and the manager phones the successful candidate. They agree a salary and start date. Later, someone says the arrangement can still be changed because the candidate has not signed the contract.


We recommend checking what was offered and accepted before making that assumption. GOV.UK explains that an accepted unconditional offer creates a binding employment contract, and that both offer and acceptance can be verbal or written.


Agree the offer before making the call


We suggest setting a clear approval point before the manager contacts the candidate. Confirm the role, salary, hours, location, proposed start date and any other terms being offered.


Decide who may discuss changes. If a candidate asks for a different working pattern or an additional benefit, the manager should know whether they can agree it or need to return for approval.


This prevents a situation where the hiring manager, HR and payroll each hold a different understanding of the same conversation.


Make conditions clear


Acas recommends identifying whether an offer is conditional and setting out any conditions, alongside the terms and acceptance arrangements. Relevant checks depend on the role and must be handled lawfully.


We recommend explaining conditions clearly at the time of the offer, rather than assuming a later letter will introduce them retrospectively. Give the candidate an appropriate contact for questions and keep an accurate record of what was communicated.


Avoid describing an offer as final when material approval or checks remain outstanding. The wording should match the actual recruitment stage.


Record the conversation and acceptance


Acas says an offer can be made verbally but recommends writing it down to avoid misunderstandings. We suggest confirming the agreed position promptly after a call and checking the written version against the manager’s notes.


Record how the candidate responds, including any requested changes. A reply that proposes different terms needs attention; do not assume every response means the original offer has been accepted exactly as issued.


Make sure colleagues arranging equipment, induction and payroll receive the confirmed information through an agreed route.


Take advice if circumstances change


GOV.UK explains that withdrawing an accepted unconditional offer, or an offer whose conditions have been met, can expose the employer to a breach-of-contract claim.


We recommend gathering the offer, correspondence, acceptance and check results before deciding what to do. Identify the reason plans have changed and obtain advice on the contractual position and any discrimination issues. Avoid relying on the absence of a signature as the whole explanation.


Prepare the start properly


The offer is one stage of recruitment. Acas also explains that the written statement of main employment particulars must be provided on or before the first day of work.


We recommend checking that the starter pack, payroll instructions and manager’s induction plan agree. If something remains unresolved, give it an owner and a date for resolution rather than leaving the employee to discover the discrepancy on arrival.


At The HFactor, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to recruitment, HR audits and management support. We help employers connect decisions made during hiring with the arrangements delivered afterwards.


For a initial meeting about job offers or your recruitment process, visit www.the-hfactor.com and complete our enquiry form.


Sources checked 24 October 2026


GOV.UK — Job offers and acceptance



Acas — Offering someone a job



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page