top of page

A witness asks for anonymity: what should an employer do next?

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 30
2 min read

A witness says they have relevant information but do not want their name shared. The investigator wants to reassure them and obtain the facts. A promise of permanent anonymity may feel like the quickest solution, yet it can create difficulties later.


We recommend understanding the person's concern before agreeing how their evidence will be handled. Confidentiality, anonymity and a fair opportunity to answer allegations need careful consideration together.


Understand the concern


Acas advises investigators to explore why a witness is reluctant, provide reassurance and try to resolve their concerns. It recommends avoiding anonymous statements wherever possible and using them only in exceptional circumstances, such as a genuine fear of reprisals.


We suggest asking what the witness is worried about in practical terms. Is the concern about daily contact, a reporting relationship or something already said? Record the concern accurately rather than reducing it to “does not want to be involved”.


Decide what can be promised


Explain how the investigation will work and who may need information to carry out their role. Acas warns that witness names may need to be shared if legal proceedings follow. Do not promise an outcome outside the employer's control.


We recommend obtaining advice before agreeing an exceptional arrangement. Consider how the information could be tested, what other evidence exists and whether removing identifying details would leave an account that can still be understood. Document the reasoning rather than treating anonymity as a routine preference.


Keep the interview focused


An investigation meeting should help establish facts, not recruit someone to support a preferred conclusion. Acas recommends explaining the reason for the meeting, giving reasonable notice and arranging a private setting.


We suggest preparing open questions around the relevant events. Clarify what the person directly observed and what they learned from somebody else. Where an answer is uncertain, keep that uncertainty visible. Avoid filling gaps in the account because an explanation seems likely.


Check the record


Give the witness an opportunity to check the accuracy of their statement. If the account changes, understand the reason and preserve a clear record of what has been amended.


We recommend keeping the statement separate from the investigator's analysis. The reader should be able to distinguish what the witness said from the investigator's assessment of it. A polished summary should not obscure a qualification or a point the witness could not confirm.


Protect fairness for everyone involved


The Acas Code requires necessary investigation and an opportunity for the employee to respond before disciplinary decisions are made. It normally expects relevant written evidence, which may include witness statements, to accompany notification of a disciplinary case.


We suggest reviewing whether any proposed redaction still allows a meaningful response. Seek advice where privacy concerns and procedural fairness are difficult to reconcile. An investigator should explain limitations in the evidence rather than presenting an unresolved concern as an established fact.


At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations, workplace investigations and management training. For a free initial consultation about planning or handling an investigation, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.


Sources checked 30 October 2026


Acas — If there are witnesses:



Acas — Holding investigation meetings:



Acas — Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures:



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page