An adjustment is not working: what should employers review before taking the next step?
An employee and manager agree an adjustment. Several weeks later, the original difficulty remains. The manager is frustrated, the employee feels unsupported and both believe they have already tried to solve the problem.
We recommend slowing the decision down enough to establish what has actually been tried. An agreement, an implementation and an effective adjustment are three different things. Understanding the gap helps an employer decide what needs to happen next.
Start with the original barrier
We suggest returning to the purpose of the arrangement. What feature of the work was creating difficulty, and how was the adjustment intended to help? A vague record such as “additional support agreed” leaves too much open to interpretation.
Ask the employee to explain their experience in practical terms. Focus on the work and the barriers rather than asking them to justify having raised the issue. Check whether both parties understood the original agreement in the same way.
Check implementation before effectiveness
A hypothetical example is an agreement to provide written task instructions. If the instructions arrive after the task is due, the arrangement has not been tested as intended.
We recommend checking dates, access, equipment and manager availability. Identify whether someone had responsibility for making the change and whether that person knew what was expected. Where implementation slipped, agree how to put it right rather than recording simply that the adjustment did not help.
Review what has changed
Acas advises reviewing adjustments regularly and when circumstances change. Changes to duties, equipment, working arrangements or the person's condition can affect what is appropriate.
We suggest comparing the current work with the work being discussed when the arrangement was agreed. New targets or an altered process may have introduced a different barrier. Ask what is helping as well as what remains difficult, so useful support is not lost in a discussion focused only on problems.
Consider alternatives with the employee
Acas recommends discussing how adjustments could work in practice and agreeing a plan to monitor them. We suggest identifying the options still available, who needs to assess them and whether further specialist input would help.
Where colleagues' needs or operational requirements create a difficulty, describe it clearly and explore alternatives. Acas recommends considering individual, team and organisational needs and obtaining legal advice before refusing an adjustment request where the position is difficult to resolve. Avoid making a rushed decision during a tense review meeting.
Keep the next decision clear
Confirm the action, owner and review point in writing. We recommend separating what the employee reported, what the employer checked and what remains unresolved. Do not treat the absence of a complaint between meetings as evidence that everything is working.
Where performance concerns continue, consider the support delivered and any outstanding adjustment issues before deciding the next procedural step. A fair assessment needs an accurate account of the working conditions.
At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations, management training and HR audits. For a free initial consultation about reviewing adjustments or supporting managers, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.
Sources checked 31 October 2026
Acas — Reviewing and keeping a record of reasonable adjustments:
https://www.acas.org.uk/reasonable-adjustments/reviewing-reasonable-adjustments-and-keeping-a-record
Acas — Having a meeting about reasonable adjustments:
Acas — Making and handling requests:
Acas — Capability and performance when someone is disabled:




Comments