top of page

An employee suggests an alternative to redundancy: how should you assess it?

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Nov 1
2 min read

A consultation meeting produces a suggestion: reduce overtime, share work differently or pause an appointment elsewhere. The manager believes the proposal will not solve the problem but cannot explain why beyond saying the business has already reviewed its options.


We recommend treating each relevant suggestion as a question to assess. Consultation needs room for employees' ideas to influence the analysis before decisions are made.


Explain the problem being addressed


Acas recommends checking why redundancies appear necessary, what problem the employer is trying to solve and which other options may be available. We suggest describing the problem precisely enough for employees to make informed suggestions.


A permanent reduction in demand raises different questions from a short period of uneven workload. If the proposal concerns a particular service or location, explain that scope. Vague references to efficiency can make it difficult for anyone to offer a useful alternative.


Identify what the suggestion could achieve


We suggest recording the idea accurately and asking how the employee sees it working. Do not dismiss a proposal because it is not presented as a complete business case.


In a hypothetical example, an overtime reduction might save some cost without addressing all the proposed savings. Establish its potential contribution before deciding whether it could form part of a wider alternative. Check the underlying assumptions rather than accepting or rejecting the headline alone.


Allocate the assessment


Name the person who will check the relevant information and set a realistic point for responding. We recommend involving the people who understand the operational implications, rather than leaving a consultation manager to improvise an answer.


Consider service coverage, skills, cost, timing and the effect on other employees. Where information is incomplete, say what still needs checking. A decision record should make uncertainty visible instead of turning an estimate into an established fact.


Check what implementation would require


Some alternatives involve changes to hours or other employment terms. Acas explains that contractual changes usually need agreement and consultation, with additional considerations following a TUPE transfer.


We recommend assessing those requirements before offering an option as immediately available. Check relevant agreements and obtain advice where needed. The fact that a suggestion could reduce redundancies does not remove the need to implement it properly.


Give a reasoned response


Acas says employers should seriously consider ideas that could avoid or reduce redundancies, including suggestions they do not accept. We suggest explaining which evidence was reviewed, what the assessment showed and why the proposal is accepted, adapted or rejected.


Allow the employee to clarify a misunderstanding or respond to an important assumption. If new information changes the assessment, update the record and the proposal. A standard response repeated to every suggestion will rarely explain the actual reasoning.


Prepare managers to keep proposals open


We recommend giving consultation managers a clear route for escalating ideas and checking answers. They need to distinguish what has been proposed from what has been decided, and understand which questions they can answer themselves.


At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to restructuring, TUPE and management training. For a free initial consultation about alternatives to redundancy or preparing a consultation process, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.


Sources checked 1 November 2026


Acas — Check redundancy is needed:



Acas — Hold consultations:



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page