top of page

Before the agency starts searching: agree a recruitment brief your managers can use

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Nov 3
2 min read

A recruiter starts searching from a job description. Meanwhile, the hiring manager has a different view of the working arrangements and the skills that matter most. Candidates receive one explanation during screening and another at interview.


We recommend agreeing a practical brief before the search begins. The document should make the role and the recruitment process clear enough for both parties to use, with someone responsible for keeping it current.


State what the role requires


We suggest identifying the work the successful candidate will actually do and the requirements needed to do it. Distinguish skills required on arrival from those the organisation can develop after appointment.


Ask the hiring manager to explain why each essential requirement matters. Avoid leaving the recruiter to translate a vague preference into a screening rule. Acas explains that discrimination law applies to advertising, interviews and selection, so the requirements and arrangements need a fair assessment from the start.


Confirm the offer being discussed


We recommend checking the approved salary range, location, hours and working arrangements before candidates are approached. State which details are fixed and which questions need approval.


If a candidate asks about an arrangement outside the brief, identify who can respond. The recruiter should not have to guess what the organisation might agree. Keep a record of clarifications that affect how the role is described, and make sure the hiring team uses the same information.


Divide the work explicitly


We suggest agreeing which checks and assessments the recruiter will carry out and what remains with the employer. Identify the information the hiring manager expects with a shortlist and how any uncertainty will be flagged.


For a hypothetical role requiring a particular qualification, decide who will verify it, at what stage and what evidence is needed. Do not let both parties assume that a mention on a CV means the other has completed the check. Relevant legal and sector requirements need their own assessment.


Keep selection responsibility visible


GOV.UK says employers must recruit fairly, including where an agency is used. We recommend retaining a clear account of how candidates are assessed against the agreed requirements.


If a hiring manager rejects a shortlist, ask for useful reasons connected to the role. “None feels right” gives the recruiter little to act on. Check whether the brief was inaccurate, evidence was missing or the manager is introducing a requirement that was never agreed. Resolve that before restarting the search.


Control changes during the campaign


We suggest giving the brief an owner and a date, then updating both parties when material details change. Decide whether candidates already in the process need revised information or further discussion.


After appointment, review where questions or misunderstandings arose. Use that learning in manager training and the next recruitment brief. An HR audit can also check whether the responsibilities agreed at the outset are reflected in the records and handover, rather than remaining assumptions between the parties.


At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to recruitment, management training and HR audits. For a free initial consultation about preparing your next vacancy or reviewing the recruitment process, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.


Sources checked 3 November 2026


GOV.UK — Employ someone: step by step:



Acas — Following discrimination law in recruitment:



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page