top of page

Beyond the handbook: a practical way to test whether HR policies work

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 19
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

An organisation may have a comprehensive handbook and still find that managers are unsure what to do when a people issue arises. The difficulty may be finding the current policy, understanding their authority or knowing when a situation requires specialist advice.


A practical HR review can explore those gaps alongside the documents themselves. One approach we recommend is a short, structured scenario exercise with the managers expected to use the policies.


Choose situations that reflect your workplace


Use hypothetical examples rather than asking managers to discuss identifiable employee cases. Select situations relevant to their responsibilities and keep the facts manageable.


For example, a new starter says they are receiving conflicting instructions. An employee disputes the objectives used in a performance review. A team member wants to raise a concern about the person who normally receives complaints.


The exercise should reveal how managers would approach the situation, including where they would stop and seek advice. It should not encourage people to guess a legal answer under pressure.


Test access to the right information


Ask managers to locate the policy or guidance they would use. Check whether they reach the current version and whether the document identifies the next step clearly.


If several versions exist, identify the authoritative copy and decide how it will be maintained. If the guidance refers to a person or role that no longer exists, assign responsibility for updating it. These are small administrative details with direct effects on how quickly a concern reaches the right person.


Check decision-making boundaries


Explore what managers believe they can decide themselves. Compare that with the organisation's actual delegation arrangements. An uncertain boundary can cause delay or lead a manager to make a commitment they were not authorised to give.


Create a simple route for urgent advice, including cover when the usual HR contact is unavailable. Employees should not have to wait for a particular individual to return before their concern can be acknowledged and directed appropriately.


Look at the quality of conversations


Use the performance scenario to ask how a manager would explain expectations and explore the employee's perspective. Acas advises that objectives should be fair, reflect normal duties and workload, and be clear and realistic.


Ask managers to practise describing the next conversation in their own words. A policy may be accurate while the manager still needs help translating it into a clear, respectful discussion. That is a training need worth identifying.


Turn findings into owned actions


Record each gap, its practical effect and who will address it. The response might be a document update, a clearer approval route, a workshop or individual coaching. Prioritise issues that could prevent an employee getting a fair response.


Repeat a focused exercise after the changes have been made. This tests whether the improvement has reached the people who need to use it. A scenario exercise complements a broader HR audit; it does not certify compliance or resolve the facts of a real case.


At The HFactor, we provide HR audits, policy reviews, bespoke half-day and full-day workshops, and individual coaching. Our team brings 85 years of combined HR experience to helping employers make their people processes usable.


Visit www.the-hfactor.com and send us an enquiry for a initial meeting.


Supporting guidance checked 19 October 2026:


Acas — Reviews and appraisals



The scenario exercise and audit questions above are The HFactor's practical recommendations, rather than a prescribed statutory process.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page