Capability or conduct? Ask better questions before choosing a procedure
Updated: Oct 29
“They are not committed.” “They are difficult.” “They just do not care.”
These phrases can reveal a manager's frustration, but they do little to explain what needs to change. We recommend translating the label into an observable concern before deciding how to respond. Which task was missed? Which instruction was not followed? What standard had been explained?
Start with the facts
Acas distinguishes capability, which concerns someone's ability to do the job, from conduct, which concerns behaviour. It also recognises that the two can overlap. An apparent behaviour problem may have a different underlying cause.
We suggest preparing a short account of the concern before the meeting. Include the expected standard, what happened and its effect on the work. Check the source of the information. A manager's direct observation, a system record and an untested report from a colleague should not be treated as interchangeable.
Make room for an explanation
Describe the concern and ask the employee to explain their perspective. Avoid opening with a conclusion about their motivation.
For example, ask how the employee understood the priorities, what resources were available and when they first realised the deadline might be missed. If instructions changed during the week, establish who changed them and how that was communicated.
We recommend separating what both sides agree happened from what remains uncertain. That makes the next action easier to explain and reduces the risk of an argument about character replacing a discussion about work.
Match the response to the cause
A skills gap may require supervised practice. Conflicting instructions may require a management decision about priorities. A concern about deliberate behaviour may require investigation under the appropriate procedure.
Where disability may be relevant, reasonable adjustment duties need consideration. Managers should not assume that an explanation involving health removes the need to address a concern, or that it can be ignored. The response needs to reflect the individual circumstances.
For capability concerns, Acas emphasises support and adequate resources, including training where needed. Any formal route must be fair; capability dismissal should be a last resort. Serious alleged misconduct may require a formal response from the outset rather than an informal coaching exercise.
Make the next step concrete
If improvement is the aim, we recommend agreeing what better performance will look like in the actual job. “Communicate more” is hard to assess. A defined handover at an agreed point in the working day is clearer.
Give support its own owner and deadline. If a manager promises training but never arranges it, the review will not tell you whether the employee could improve with that support. Check progress while there is still time to address obstacles, and share an accurate record of the discussion.
Train managers to make the judgement
Useful management training should let people practise these decisions. Give managers a scenario, ask what evidence is missing, and discuss when they should involve HR. Include the point at which an informal conversation should move into a formal process, with the relevant safeguards.
At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to management training and complex employee relations. For a initial meeting about a difficult performance or conduct concern, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.
Sources checked 26 October 2026
Acas — Problems with an employee's performance:
Acas — Dismissals for capability or conduct:




Comments