Defending an employment claim: what employers should do when the papers arrive
Updated: Oct 29
A claim arrives and the business owner’s first reaction is that the decision was justified. That may be their firm view, but defending the claim requires careful attention to the allegations, the applicable law and the evidence.
We recommend organising the response promptly. A confident recollection of events needs to be tested against the records, including information that may challenge the employer’s account.
Identify the process and deadline
Many workplace disputes, including unfair dismissal and discrimination claims, are heard in employment tribunals. A civil court claim has different procedures. Read the papers carefully before assuming which response is required.
For an employment tribunal claim, the usual deadline for the employer’s ET3 response is 28 days from the date the tribunal sends the claim. GOV.UK warns that failing to respond in time can lead to a decision without a hearing. Check the deadline stated in the papers and seek advice immediately if there is any difficulty meeting it.
For a civil money claim in England and Wales, follow the instructions and response date in the court correspondence. Do not apply the tribunal timetable to it. Scotland has a different civil process.
We recommend assigning one person to coordinate correspondence, deadlines and contact with advisers. Check any relevant insurance promptly, including notification requirements and arrangements for appointing advisers.
Preserve the original evidence
We recommend securing relevant contracts, policies, payroll information, correspondence, meeting notes and messages. Identify material held by managers or in systems scheduled for deletion, and arrange appropriate preservation with advice where needed.
Keep original records intact. If someone now recalls a conversation that was not documented, record that recollection honestly as a later account, with its actual date. Do not present it as a note made at the time.
Include relevant information that raises difficult questions. Advisers need an accurate picture to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the case.
Build a timeline linked to documents
We suggest a chronology showing the date, event, people involved and supporting record. Distinguish an established fact from a disputed account or an assumption.
Then map the main allegations against that chronology. What does the claimant say happened? What is the employer’s response? Which records or witnesses address the point?
This helps identify missing information before a response depends on it. It also makes the case easier for an adviser to understand without repeatedly asking managers to retell the whole history.
Prepare people and follow directions
Identify who directly saw, heard or decided something relevant. We recommend asking witnesses to explain events in their own words and distinguish personal knowledge from what somebody else told them.
GOV.UK explains that tribunal preparation includes arranging relevant documents and witnesses. The tribunal will usually issue a timetable for exchanging documents. Follow the actual orders in your case, including any requirements for statements or hearing preparation.
Agree who is responsible for each task. Managers need to understand both the time commitment and where they should obtain guidance.
Assess the options with appropriate support
We recommend reviewing the legal merits, evidence gaps, potential exposure, management time and practical options with the appropriate advisers. Consider any opportunity to resolve the dispute alongside preparation for defending it. Do not assume discussions change a formal deadline.
At The HFactor, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations. We can help employers organise the HR facts, review the process followed and prepare information for their legal advisers. Agree the scope of support, responsibility for formal responses and any representation separately.
For a initial meeting about an employment dispute or claim preparation, visit www.the-hfactor.com and complete our enquiry form. Tell us the stage reached and flag any imminent deadline straight away.
Sources checked 23 October 2026
GOV.UK — Being taken to an employment tribunal
HM Courts & Tribunals Service — How to respond to an employment tribunal claim (T422)
GOV.UK — Preparing for an employment tribunal hearing
GOV.UK — Responding to a court claim for money




Comments