Family-Run Business? Why Informal HR Stops Working as You Grow
Updated: 3 days ago
Family-run businesses are often built on trust, loyalty and close working relationships.
That can be a real strength. Decisions are made quickly, people pull together and the business may feel more personal than a large organisation.
However, difficulties can arise when the workforce grows beyond the family. Informal arrangements that worked for a small founding team may begin to feel unclear or unfair to employees who are not relatives.
“We are like a family” is not an HR process
A supportive culture is valuable, but employees still need to know what is expected of them, how decisions are made and what will happen if a concern arises.
Problems often begin when important matters are handled differently depending on who is involved. A family member may be allowed flexibility that is not offered to another employee. A relative may receive information before the wider team. Performance concerns may be avoided because the conversation feels too personal.
Even when there is no intention to treat anyone unfairly, employees may perceive favouritism. Once trust is affected, an informal conversation may not be enough to repair it.
Where growing family businesses commonly struggle
As the organisation develops, the following issues often become more difficult:
• unclear job descriptions and reporting lines
• family members managing people without management training
• inconsistent pay, working hours or flexibility
• undocumented performance and conduct concerns
• confidential information being discussed informally
• uncertainty about who has authority to make decisions
• relatives being involved in grievances or investigations
• policies that exist on paper but are not followed in practice
These issues do not mean that the business has lost its family values. They are signs that the people framework has not yet caught up with the organisation’s growth.
Clear processes protect relationships
Many business owners worry that formal HR procedures will make the workplace cold or corporate.
In reality, proportionate processes often protect the very relationships the business values. They reduce misunderstandings, help managers explain decisions and give employees confidence that concerns will be handled fairly.
The aim is not to produce unnecessary paperwork. It is to create enough clarity for everyone to understand the rules.
That may include:
• up-to-date contracts and job descriptions
• simple, relevant workplace policies
• consistent induction for every employee
• clear lines of management responsibility
• fair approaches to absence, conduct and performance
• a confidential route for raising concerns
• accurate records of important conversations and decisions
The same standards should apply to everyone
One of the hardest questions for a family business is whether a family member is genuinely being managed in the same way as another employee.
This becomes particularly important when there is a complaint, performance issue, promotion opportunity or restructure.
A decision may be commercially sensible, but the business should still be able to explain the reason for it and demonstrate that a fair approach was followed.
Where a family relationship creates a conflict of interest, an independent person may need to conduct the investigation or advise on the outcome. Independence can protect the business, the employee and the family relationships involved.
Managers need support, not just policies
A policy cannot have a difficult conversation.
Managers need the confidence to raise concerns early, listen properly, remain objective and avoid making promises before the facts are known. This is especially important when managers are supervising former colleagues, friends or relatives.
Practical management training and access to experienced HR guidance can prevent an everyday issue from becoming a grievance or a wider workplace dispute.
Do not wait for a crisis
Family-run businesses often seek HR support only after a complaint has been raised or a relationship has broken down.
By that point, the options may be narrower and the situation more stressful.
An HR review completed during a period of growth can identify gaps before they become urgent. It can also help the business retain its character while introducing the structure needed for a larger and more diverse workforce.
How The HFactor can help
The HFactor works with small and growing businesses that need experienced HR guidance without employing a permanent senior HR professional.
Support can include:
• reviewing contracts, policies and working practices
• clarifying roles and reporting arrangements
• management training and coaching
• handling grievances, disciplinaries and investigations
• absence and performance management
• redundancy, restructuring and organisational change
• independent support where family relationships create a conflict
• temporary HR cover or ongoing advice
Support is flexible and can be provided for one day, one project or on an ongoing basis.
Led by Karen Lewis Chartered FCIPD, The HFactor brings 35 years’ HR experience and access to a trusted UK-wide consortium of highly skilled HR specialists.
If your family-run business now employs people outside the family, arrange a free initial consultation.
Tell us how the business has grown and where the people challenges are appearing. We will help you introduce the right level of structure without losing the culture that made the business successful.
The HFactor HR Consultancy
Flexible, experienced HR support for UK employers
Got an HR problem you need to resolve?
Tell us what is happening in your organisation. The HFactor offers a confidential, free initial consultation to help identify your priority HR risks and a practical next step.
Comments