top of page

Flexible Working Requests: Five Mistakes Employers Should Avoid

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 18
2 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Flexible working has become an important consideration for employers. Employees may request different hours, compressed weeks, homeworking or changes to their usual workplace. Organisations must balance operational needs with individual circumstances and legal responsibilities. A poorly handled request can harm workplace relationships and expose employers to avoidable risks.

1. Assuming employees need a minimum period of service

Employees can make a statutory flexible working request from their first day of employment. This is a right to request, not an automatic right to the arrangement. Managers should not reject requests simply because an employee has only recently joined.

2. Refusing a request without consultation

Where an employer is considering refusing a statutory flexible working request, it must consult the employee before deciding. A discussion might reveal a workable compromise, trial period or alternative working pattern. Consultation does not guarantee agreement, but it allows an informed decision.

3. Missing the decision deadline

Employers must normally make a final decision within two months of receiving a statutory flexible working request, including any appeal. An extension can be agreed with the employee. A clear process for tracking requests and deadlines helps managers respond consistently.

4. Failing to explain a permitted business reason

Refusal must be based on one or more of the statutory business grounds, such as additional costs, detrimental impact on quality or performance, or inability to meet customer demand. Explain specifically how the reason applies to the request. A general preference for office attendance is not itself a statutory ground.

5. Forgetting to update employment documentation

When a statutory flexible working request is approved, agreed contractual changes should be documented. Written terms reflecting changes in hours, days or working location must be provided within the applicable timeframe. Employers should be clear about any temporary or trial arrangement.

Why management training matters

Line managers are often the first people to receive flexible working requests. Without training, some may refuse too quickly while others may agree arrangements without assessing operational effects. Practical management training helps employers make fair, consistent, commercially informed decisions.

How The HFactor can help

The HFactor provides HR policy reviews, employee relations advice, management training and complex workforce support. We offer bespoke half-day and full-day workshops and individual coaching. With 85 years of combined HR experience, including Chartered FCIPD expertise, we help employers handle challenging employment situations.

Need support with flexible working requests?

Whether managers are applying inconsistent rules, employees are challenging decisions or procedures need reviewing, The HFactor can help. Contact us at https://www.the-hfactor.com/ for a initial meeting.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page