Flexible working requests: replace assumptions with an operational plan
Updated: Oct 29
A flexible working request can quickly become a debate about fairness, commitment or what other employees might ask for next. We recommend bringing the discussion back to the job. What needs to happen, when does it need to happen, and which parts genuinely require a particular working pattern?
This gives managers a practical starting point and employees a meaningful opportunity to explain their proposal.
Know which decision you are making
In Great Britain, employees have a statutory right to request flexible working from their first day of employment. That is a right to request a change, rather than an automatic entitlement to the pattern requested.
Unless the employer accepts the request in full, consultation must take place before a decision. The normal two-month decision period includes any appeal, although a longer period can be agreed. We suggest recording the receipt date, decision owner and key meetings immediately, so diary availability does not quietly consume the timetable.
Describe the operational issue precisely
“We need everyone here” is difficult to assess. “We need two trained people available between 3pm and 5pm to complete a particular handover” gives everyone something concrete to work with.
We recommend preparing a short picture of the work: demand by time of day, responsibilities that need continuity, tasks that can move, and responsibilities that cannot. Ask the employee how their proposed arrangement would address those requirements. Avoid treating an untested concern as an established fact.
Refusal of a statutory request must rest on one or more of the permitted business grounds. These include effects on customer demand, quality or performance. A decision letter should explain how the relevant ground applies to the actual role, rather than simply copying a heading from a policy.
Consider what could be tested
Where there is uncertainty, we recommend discussing alternatives before closing the conversation. These might involve different start times, a revised handover or a different distribution of duties.
If both sides agree to a trial, define its duration, working arrangements, review points and measures of success. Decide what happens at the end. A trial should answer a specific question, such as whether a proposed handover maintains service cover. It should not leave the employee guessing whether the arrangement is temporary or permanent.
Keep the review timetable aligned with the statutory decision deadline. If more time is needed, agree and record the extension rather than assuming that a trial pauses the process.
Make the agreement usable
An accepted arrangement needs more than a positive email. We recommend checking how it affects rotas, responsibilities, communication and payroll, then documenting the agreed contractual changes. Tell colleagues what they need to know about availability and cover without discussing the employee's private circumstances unnecessarily.
Where disability is involved, consider reasonable adjustment duties separately. Completing the flexible working procedure does not replace that assessment.
Build the skill before the next request
Managers benefit from rehearsing the conversation: asking open questions, testing assumptions and explaining a decision respectfully. We can help employers combine a workable policy with management training and support for complex employee relations.
At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to practical employer support. For a initial meeting about flexible working or management training, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.
Sources checked 25 October 2026
Acas — The right to request:
Acas — Making a decision:
GOV.UK — Flexible working: after the application:




Comments