Flexible Working Requests: What Managers Should Do Before Saying Yes or No
Updated: Oct 29
Flexible working is an important consideration for employers across many industries. Employees may request changes to working hours, patterns or workplace arrangements for caring responsibilities, health conditions, commuting difficulties or changing circumstances. Employers need to balance individual requests with operational requirements and understand that statutory rules apply to qualifying requests. Here are seven considerations for managers.
1. Understand the employee's statutory rights
Employees have the right to make a statutory flexible working request from their first day of employment and can generally make up to two statutory requests in 12 months. This is a right to request, not an automatic entitlement to the arrangement. Employers can refuse on one or more of the permitted statutory business grounds, provided the applicable requirements are met.
2. Don't reject a request without consultation
Before refusing a statutory flexible working request, employers must consult the employee. A discussion can help clarify operational concerns and explore alternatives such as a different working pattern or trial arrangement. Consultation does not guarantee agreement but enables an informed decision.
3. Consider the business impact objectively
Flexible working can affect customer service, staffing, workloads and business demand. Managers should distinguish genuine operational difficulties from personal preferences. A preference for identical working hours is not itself a statutory ground for refusal. Identify the relevant business reason and consider whether the concerns can be addressed.
4. Remember the decision-making deadline
Employers must normally reach and communicate a final decision, including any appeal, within two months of receiving a statutory flexible working request. The period can be extended by agreement with the employee. Organisations should track requests, responsibilities and deadlines so that decisions are not delayed.
5. Consider discrimination and reasonable adjustments
Some requests may engage separate discrimination law obligations. An employee with a disability may require reasonable adjustments to working arrangements. Employers must consider this duty separately from the statutory flexible working procedure where it applies. Other circumstances can also create indirect discrimination concerns, so seek appropriate advice where necessary.
6. Explain decisions clearly
Where a request is agreed, confirm the arrangement and any relevant contractual changes. Where a statutory request is refused, explain the permitted business reason or reasons and communicate professionally. Employees may disagree with the outcome, but should understand how their request was considered. Any appeal should be handled appropriately within the statutory decision period unless extended by agreement.
7. Train managers before difficult requests arise
A good policy cannot replace competent management. Managers need to know how to assess requests, consult employees, document decisions and recognise when specialist HR advice is required. Training can help distinguish statutory requests, informal arrangements and requests involving reasonable adjustments. The HFactor offers bespoke half-day and full-day management workshops and individual coaching.
Employment law developments
Further flexible working reforms are planned under the Employment Rights Act 2025, including changes concerning the reasonableness of refusals and consultation. A revised Acas Code of Practice is subject to consultation closing on 17 December 2026. Employers should follow current requirements while preparing for future changes.
How The HFactor can help
The HFactor supports employers with employment contract changes, flexible working requests, employee relations, HR policies and management training. We help organisations review individual requests, develop consistent procedures and improve management confidence. Our team brings 85 years of combined HR experience, including Chartered FCIPD expertise, with advice tailored to operational and commercial needs.
Is your organisation struggling with flexible working requests?
Whether a manager is unsure how to handle a request, policies need reviewing or your team would benefit from training, The HFactor can help. Contact us through the enquiry form at https://www.the-hfactor.com/ for a initial meeting. The HFactor — practical HR support for employers.




Comments