top of page

Is your workplace becoming a Traitors round table?

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 10
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

The Traitors makes compelling television because it puts trust, suspicion and human behaviour under pressure. A small comment becomes a theory. A confident accusation gathers support. Before long, people are making decisions without knowing whether their assumptions are correct.


For anyone who manages people, there is a useful question here: could the same thing be happening in your workplace?


When suspicion becomes a workplace problem


An employee goes quiet in a meeting. A colleague seems defensive. Someone hears part of a conversation and fills in the gaps.


These observations can quickly become labels: “difficult”, “dishonest” or “not a team player”. Once a label takes hold, people may interpret everything that person does as confirmation.


But quietness can reflect anxiety. Defensiveness can come from feeling unfairly accused. A disagreement may reveal a problem that others have overlooked.


Managers need to be curious about what happened before deciding what it means.


The loudest voice is not always the most reliable


At a round table—or in a team meeting—a confident speaker can influence the room. People may agree because they trust that person, want to fit in or feel uncomfortable challenging them.


That is a risk when workplace concerns arise. Several people repeating the same story may all have heard it from one source.


A useful management question is: “What did you personally see or hear?”


It helps separate direct knowledge from interpretation and rumour. Managers should also make space for quieter colleagues, who may have relevant information but feel reluctant to speak.


A workplace investigation should never become a popularity vote


When allegations arise, the aim is to understand what happened through a fair process.


That means considering relevant records, speaking to the people involved, checking conflicting accounts and giving the person facing an allegation a proper opportunity to respond.


An investigator also needs to remain open to information that challenges their initial view. Looking only for evidence that supports a suspicion can lead to an unreliable conclusion.


Someone’s popularity, confidence or nervousness should not substitute for evidence.


Trust depends on how managers respond


Employees notice how concerns are handled.


If managers dismiss questions, encourage gossip or appear to have decided the outcome in advance, people may stop speaking openly. Problems then become harder to identify and resolve.


Trust grows when managers listen, explain the process and handle sensitive information carefully. They can take a concern seriously while keeping an open mind about the outcome.


Employees should feel able to raise concerns, disagree respectfully and admit mistakes without becoming the next target of office speculation.


Give managers the skills to handle difficult situations


Many managers are promoted because they are good at their jobs, then find themselves handling conflict, absence, performance concerns and grievances with little practical preparation.


Training can help them recognise when an informal conversation is appropriate, when to seek HR support and how to approach sensitive discussions calmly.


At The HFactor, our Management Training & Development covers disciplinary and grievance procedures, absence management, performance management, recruitment, leadership and communication. We offer bespoke half-day and full-day workshops and individual coaching.


We can help you find a way forward


With 35 years of practical HR experience, Karen Lewis, Chartered FCIPD, brings hands-on experience of complex employee relations and supporting managers through difficult decisions.


Whether you are dealing with a grievance, an allegation or a team where trust is breaking down, The HFactor can help you establish the facts and take practical steps forward.


Is a workplace issue taking up too much of your time? Contact us through the enquiry form at www.the-hfactor.com for a initial meeting.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page