Management Training: Why Promoting Your Best Employee Isn't Enough
Updated: Oct 29
One of the most common mistakes organisations make is assuming that technical ability automatically translates into management capability.
An employee may be excellent at their job, achieve outstanding results, understand the business and consistently exceed expectations.
Naturally, management identifies them as someone with leadership potential.
They receive a promotion, perhaps a salary increase, and responsibility for other employees.
But what happens next? Who teaches them how to manage people?
In many organisations, nobody does.
The responsibilities change overnight
Yesterday, the employee was responsible primarily for their own performance.
Today, they may be responsible for the performance, conduct, development and wellbeing of other people.
They may need to manage poor performance, repeated lateness, sickness absence, workplace disagreements, recruitment decisions, disciplinary procedures, employee grievances, flexible working and personal problems affecting work.
These situations require knowledge, judgement and communication skills.
Managers need to understand conduct and capability
Consider an employee who is not meeting their targets.
Is the issue poor performance because they lack the necessary skills? Have expectations been communicated properly? Are they receiving adequate training? Or is there evidence that the employee is deliberately refusing to follow reasonable instructions?
These situations may require different approaches.
Good management training helps people understand the problem before deciding on the process.
Difficult conversations should not be avoided
Managers regularly encounter conversations they would rather not have.
An employee's performance has deteriorated. A colleague has made a complaint. Someone's attendance is causing operational difficulties. A team member behaves inappropriately. An employee believes they are being treated unfairly.
Ignoring these matters rarely makes them disappear.
Effective training should help managers prepare, establish the facts, communicate expectations and document agreements.
Absence management requires more than checking fit notes
Sickness absence can be particularly challenging for inexperienced managers.
Managers need to understand how to maintain appropriate contact, consider occupational health support, recognise possible disability-related issues and explore reasonable adjustments where required.
They also need to understand the organisation's policies and when to involve HR.
Investigations require proper preparation
One of the most serious mistakes an inexperienced manager can make is assuming an allegation must be true before it has been investigated.
The purpose of an investigation is to establish the relevant facts and determine whether further action is appropriate.
Managers who may conduct investigations should understand their responsibilities and receive appropriate training.
Recruitment is another management skill
Recruitment decisions can have long-term consequences.
Recruitment training should help managers understand job requirements, structured interviews, fair selection, recordkeeping and onboarding.
At The HFactor, we have practical recruitment experience, including delivering an assignment involving 13 positions filled within two weeks.
Management training should reflect real workplace situations
Generic training material can provide useful background information, but managers often need more than theory.
They need to know what to say when an employee becomes upset, how to handle a difficult meeting, how to respond when somebody refuses an instruction, what to do when a grievance involves another manager, when to involve HR and how to avoid making a difficult situation worse.
Practical scenarios, role-playing and case discussions can help managers prepare for situations they may encounter at work.
The HFactor's approach to Management Training & Development
The HFactor offers management training grounded in practical HR experience.
With 35 years of HR experience, our lead consultant understands the challenges managers face when dealing with employees and organisational change.
We offer bespoke half-day workshops, full-day workshops and individual coaching.
Training topics include disciplinary and grievance procedures, managing performance, sickness absence, recruitment, leadership, communication and managing organisational change.
We can also help managers understand their responsibilities during redundancy and TUPE processes.
What does effective management training achieve?
Good management training should produce observable improvements.
Managers should understand their responsibilities, recognise problems earlier, know how to follow company procedures, feel more confident holding difficult conversations and understand when specialist HR advice is required.
Training is not only for new managers
Experienced managers can also benefit from development.
Employment practices change, organisations restructure, employee expectations evolve and new challenges emerge.
Training can also be particularly valuable after a TUPE transfer or organisational restructure, when managers inherit new teams and responsibilities.
How The HFactor can help
The HFactor works with organisations requiring practical, experienced HR support.
Our Management Training & Development programmes can be delivered as tailored workshops or individual coaching.
Have you promoted employees into management without providing the training they need? Or do you have experienced managers who would benefit from practical HR development?
Speak to The HFactor about a bespoke management training programme. Request your initial meeting at https://www.the-hfactor.com/




Comments