Protected conversations: what employers should check before opening the discussion
A manager wants to resolve a difficult situation and suggests an “off the record” meeting. That phrase may sound reassuring, but it does not settle whether the discussion could later be used as evidence.
We recommend deciding the purpose, legal basis and practical approach before anyone opens a settlement conversation. The meeting should be part of a considered response to the situation, with clear authority and realistic expectations.
Understand the limits of confidentiality
Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 can protect pre-termination negotiations in ordinary unfair dismissal claims, even without an existing dispute. It does not provide the same protection for discrimination, wrongful dismissal or automatically unfair dismissal claims, including those involving whistleblowing. Improper behaviour can also affect protection.
The separate without prejudice principle generally requires an existing dispute and a genuine attempt to settle it, and has exceptions for serious wrongdoing. Do not assume that adding either label to an email creates protection. Get advice on which rules apply to the actual circumstances.
Clarify what you are trying to resolve
We suggest preparing a short account of the problem and the options already considered. Is the organisation trying to resolve an existing dispute, explore an agreed departure or address an ongoing performance concern?
This helps identify what a discussion could achieve and what still needs attention separately. If an operational problem remains, decide who will manage it while discussions continue. Avoid leaving the employee and manager uncertain about ordinary responsibilities during the process.
Give the manager a clear brief
Identify who can make an offer and the limits of their authority. We recommend agreeing how questions about payments, dates, references and next steps will be handled before the meeting.
The manager should be able to explain why a discussion is being proposed without presenting an allegation as a proven finding. They should also know when to pause and obtain advice. A script can help preparation, but it should not prevent the employee asking questions or explaining their position.
Allow a voluntary decision
Acas makes clear that settlement agreements are voluntary. Its Code generally recommends at least 10 calendar days to consider formal written terms and obtain independent advice, unless otherwise agreed. Legal validity also depends on statutory requirements, including advice from a relevant independent adviser.
We recommend planning enough time for the individual circumstances, including any adjustments needed. Do not turn an offer into a threat that dismissal is inevitable if it is refused. Check the approach with legal advisers before communicating it.
Plan for no agreement
An offer may not be accepted. We suggest deciding in advance how any ongoing process will continue fairly, without treating the refusal itself as misconduct or proof of a performance problem.
Keep an accurate record of the decisions and obtain advice on handling settlement material. The confidentiality assessment and any underlying employment issue need careful attention throughout.
At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations, restructuring and management training. For a free initial consultation about the HR approach to a difficult employment situation, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.
Sources checked 29 October 2026
Acas — Code of Practice on settlement agreements:
Acas — Confidentiality:
Acas — Discussing and negotiating an offer:




Comments