top of page

Questions to ask during redundancy consultation

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 13
2 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Helping employees understand the proposal and employers respond clearly

Questions help turn uncertainty into a useful discussion

A consultation meeting should leave people clearer about the proposal, its reasons and the next steps. Asking focused questions helps employees identify what they need to understand and helps employers see where their explanation or evidence needs more work.

Understand the business proposal

Start with the reason for the proposed change. Ask what work is reducing or changing, which roles are affected and what alternatives have been explored. Ask which decisions are still open and how further suggestions can be submitted. Genuine consultation takes place before final redundancy decisions.

Understand selection

Where selection is required, useful questions include: Why has this selection pool been proposed? What criteria and weightings will be used? Who will assess the evidence? How can inaccurate information be corrected? Acas advises using objective, measurable criteria and applying them consistently.

Explore other possibilities

Ask about available roles, retraining or other arrangements that might avoid a dismissal. If a different role is proposed, ask for its duties, location, hours, pay and any relevant trial arrangements in writing. Ask how your own suggestions will be considered.

Clarify the next steps

Ask when the next meeting will take place, when outstanding questions will be answered and how the eventual outcome will be communicated. Request an explanation of notice, payments and the applicable appeal process. GOV.UK explains that an employee who believes selection was unfair can write to the employer to appeal.

For managers leading the meeting

Prepare answers that explain the proposal rather than simply repeat it. Where you cannot answer, record the question and agree a realistic response date. Never promise that an employee will retain their job, or imply that the outcome is fixed, when the process has not concluded.

How The HFactor can help

We support employers with meeting preparation, selection processes, clear communications and manager coaching. Employees seeking help with their next career step can ask about our practical redundancy transition support. Our work draws on 35 years of HR experience, led by a Chartered Fellow of the CIPD.

Discuss your HR situation with us in a initial meeting. Send an enquiry and we will agree a convenient time, then email your invitation. Scope and fees are agreed before paid work begins.

Sources

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page