Redundancies in one team, recruitment in another: have you connected the decisions?
Updated: Oct 29
A business may be reducing roles in one department while recruiting in another. There can be sound reasons for this: the work, skills or location may be different. Even so, the decisions deserve to be considered together.
Before starting a redundancy process, Acas advises employers to examine the problem they are trying to solve and consider other options. A review of vacancies and skills can help turn that principle into a practical discussion.
Describe the business problem clearly
Start with what needs to change. Is demand falling, a service ending, work moving or the organisation seeking a different mix of skills? Identify the activities affected and the assumptions behind the proposed structure.
A clear explanation gives managers a basis for testing alternatives. Without it, an option may be dismissed because it differs from the original plan, rather than because it fails to address the business need.
Bring vacancies into the same review
Gather current vacancies, authorised recruitment and roles likely to become available. Check who controls this information across departments or sites. A vacancy known to one manager may be invisible to the person leading the restructure.
For each role, record the duties, essential requirements, location, hours and proposed start date. This helps the organisation examine potential matches rather than relying on job titles alone. GOV.UK lists restricting recruitment and filling vacancies with existing employees among the steps employers can consider to avoid compulsory redundancies.
Look at skills with an open mind
Review the experience employees already have, including work they have done before joining the organisation. Consider whether a realistic amount of training could address a gap. Do not promise that every role can be adapted; equally, avoid assuming that a different job title rules out a match.
Ask employees about their experience and interests. A manager's understanding of someone's skills may be incomplete, particularly where the employee has moved between roles or developed skills outside their current duties.
Assess suggestions consistently
Acas says employers should seriously consider proposals that could avoid or reduce redundancies. That does not mean every proposal must be accepted.
Use a clear method to assess the suggestion against the business problem. Consider operational feasibility, costs, timescales, training and the effects on service delivery. Keep a record of what was explored, what information was checked and the reasons for the conclusion. Explain the response during consultation so the employee understands how their proposal was considered.
Check obligations before making offers
GOV.UK states that employers must try to find suitable alternative work for someone selected for redundancy. Some employees also have priority rights to suitable alternative vacancies. Obtain advice on the applicable rights and process before deciding how to allocate roles.
Where a restructure overlaps with a TUPE transfer, seek advice on the transfer-related considerations as well. A general vacancy review does not resolve every legal or contractual issue.
At The HFactor, we support employers with restructuring, redundancy consultation, TUPE, recruitment and management support. Our team brings 85 years of combined HR experience to helping organisations examine their options and manage change carefully.
To arrange a initial meeting, visit www.the-hfactor.com and send us an enquiry.
Sources checked 19 October 2026:
Acas — Check redundancy is needed
Acas — Redundancy consultations
GOV.UK — Avoiding redundancies




Comments