top of page

Redundancy Selection: Eight Mistakes Employers Must Avoid When Restructuring

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Nov 7
3 min read

Restructuring can be necessary when organisations face financial pressures, changing requirements or a need to improve efficiency. But deciding that fewer roles are required is only the beginning. Employers must consider how employees are identified, consulted and, where needed, selected. Poor selection procedures can create disputes and damage trust. Here are eight mistakes to avoid.

1. Deciding who should leave before consultation begins

Management may have strong views about individuals, but redundancy should focus on genuine business requirements and fair procedures. Explain the proposed changes, invite suggestions and consider alternatives. Consultation must be meaningful rather than an announcement of an irreversible decision.

2. Failing to identify an appropriate selection pool

Where several employees perform similar work and fewer positions are needed, an appropriate selection pool may be necessary. Consider which employees do comparable work and whether skills are interchangeable. Not every redundancy requires competitive scoring, particularly when a genuinely unique role disappears. Document the rationale for the pool chosen.

3. Using subjective selection criteria

Comments such as 'difficult attitude' or 'not a team player' can conceal personal preferences. Criteria should be relevant, objective and measurable where possible. Skills, qualifications, experience and appropriately evidenced performance may be relevant. Apply criteria consistently and explain them during consultation.

4. Scoring without supporting evidence

A selection matrix should be supported by reliable records, not memory or opinion. Relevant evidence may include competency assessments, qualifications and documented performance information. Consider moderation of scores and provide affected employees with a meaningful opportunity to challenge relevant assessments.

5. Overlooking discrimination risks

Selection methods must not unlawfully discriminate. Particular care is needed when assessing attendance affected by pregnancy, maternity or disability. Consider reasonable adjustments and review whether apparently neutral criteria disproportionately disadvantage protected groups without lawful justification.

6. Failing to consult meaningfully

Explain the business rationale, selection approach and alternatives under consideration. Listen to employee suggestions and genuinely consider challenges. Collective consultation requirements may apply depending on the number and timing of proposed redundancies. Identify the correct legal obligations before starting the process.

7. Ignoring suitable alternative employment

Review relevant vacancies and potential redeployment options before concluding that dismissal is necessary. Certain employees, including pregnant employees and those in specified protected periods associated with maternity, adoption or shared parental leave, have priority rights to suitable alternative vacancies. Understand and apply these rules carefully.

8. Failing to maintain accurate records

Keep the business rationale, selection criteria, scoring evidence, consultation notes, communications and decisions. Store records securely and in accordance with data protection requirements. A clear audit trail supports transparency and helps explain decisions.

What happens when selection goes wrong?

Employees may challenge redundancy dismissals on grounds including unfair selection, inadequate consultation, discrimination or failure to follow appropriate procedures. Poorly managed restructuring can also undermine morale, trust and retention among employees who remain.

Why early HR involvement matters

Independent HR support can help employers assess the business rationale, identify appropriate pools, design selection criteria, prepare consultation documents and guide managers through difficult decisions. Early involvement can reduce avoidable risks and support practical outcomes.

How The HFactor can help

At The HFactor, redundancy, restructuring and organisational change are specialist services. Our team brings 85 years of combined HR experience, including Chartered FCIPD expertise. We support workforce planning, redundancy consultation, selection assessments, employment documentation, redeployment, complex employee relations, TUPE transfers and management training. Our advice is practical and commercially focused.

Considering changes to your workforce?

Whether you need to reduce costs, reorganise departments or respond to a service transfer, experienced HR advice can help you identify obligations and manage change appropriately. Request your initial meeting at https://www.the-hfactor.com/. The HFactor — Practical HR solutions for employers.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page