Redundancy selection pools: the question to examine before opening the scoring spreadsheet
Updated: Oct 29
A scoring spreadsheet can look reassuringly precise. Each person has a row, each criterion has a weighting and the totals appear to provide a clear answer.
But scoring does not explain why those employees were compared in the first place. When a proposal involves reducing the number of people doing work, we recommend examining that question before relying on the figures.
Begin with the work and the proposed change
Write down what the organisation proposes to change and why. Identify which work would reduce, end or be organised differently, and what work would remain.
We recommend keeping this explanation separate from any individual assessment. It should be possible to discuss the business proposal without starting with a preferred list of names.
Then ask managers to describe the duties people actually perform. A role title may have stayed the same while responsibilities expanded or moved between teams.
Check the proposed pool against the evidence
Acas guidance says selection pools should include the same or similar roles, with consideration also given to roles involving similar skills. Employers should check relevant redundancy policies and trade union agreements.
Our practical recommendation is to assemble a brief evidence pack: current role information, reporting arrangements and a description of how work is shared. Where records disagree, identify the question that needs resolving rather than selecting whichever document supports the initial proposal.
An HR audit can help organise that work. Record the source and date of information so someone reviewing the proposal can see what the manager relied on.
Explain the boundary in plain language
We suggest drafting a short explanation of each proposed pool, including why apparently related roles have been included or excluded. Ask another appropriate person to test it.
Could the explanation be understood without seeing the organisation chart? Does it depend on an assumption about duties that nobody has checked? Would a different manager describe the work differently?
These questions help identify matters for discussion. They do not turn a preliminary pool into a settled outcome.
Keep consultation meaningful
Acas advises consulting before redundancy decisions are made and discussing the proposed selection criteria. Suggestions need genuine consideration, including where the employer ultimately does not accept them.
We recommend tracking questions about the proposed pool in the same way as other consultation points. Record what was raised, what further information was checked and how the employer responded. If the proposal changes, update the explanation and communicate it clearly.
Prepare scoring only within the wider process
Acas recommends objective, measurable criteria, applied consistently within a pool and supported by written evidence. Employers must also avoid discriminatory criteria and application.
We suggest briefing assessors on how to record evidence and flag uncertainty. A number without an explanation can conceal a gap rather than resolve it. Managers also need to understand the wider process, including alternatives to redundancy and consideration of suitable vacancies.
Where TUPE is involved, obtain advice early. Acas explains that transfer-related redundancies after a transfer require a genuine redundancy situation and workforce changes for economic, technical or organisational reasons. A scoring exercise alone does not establish those grounds.
At The HFactor, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to restructuring, HR audits and TUPE support. For a initial meeting about your proposed change, visit www.the-hfactor.com and complete our enquiry form.
Sources checked 22 October 2026
Acas — Select employees for redundancy
Acas — Redundancy consultations
Acas — After a TUPE transfer, including redundancy requirements




Comments