top of page

Should we use mediation? Five questions before bringing colleagues together

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 24
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Two colleagues are struggling to work together. Their manager wants a joint meeting so everyone can move on, but the people involved may have very different views about what needs resolving.


We recommend clarifying the situation before choosing the meeting format. Mediation may be an option, but its purpose and suitability need consideration alongside any concerns requiring another response.


1. What needs to be resolved?


Write down the issue without reducing it to a personality label. Is the concern about communication, unclear responsibilities, a specific decision or alleged behaviour?


We suggest separating relationship difficulties from questions about what happened. A person seeking an investigation may not understand why they have instead been invited to discuss improving communication. Establish the concern and explain the proposed next step.


Where there is an immediate safety concern or a serious allegation, seek appropriate advice about the response required. Where formal investigation is needed, mediation should not replace it. Choosing mediation should follow assessment of the circumstances.


2. Do people understand the process?


Acas describes mediation as a voluntary and confidential process with an impartial mediator. It looks towards an agreed way of working together rather than deciding who was right or wrong in the past.


We recommend explaining how the proposed process would work, what the mediator’s role would be and how information would be handled. Check understanding separately before making arrangements for a joint session.


Do not use a meeting invitation to imply that agreement has already been reached about participation or the outcome.


3. Is participation workable for everyone?


Consider what each person needs to participate meaningfully. We recommend discussing communication needs, the proposed location or format and concerns about the working relationship.


A manager’s wish to resolve the issue quickly does not establish that the arrangement is suitable. If someone declines mediation, explore the reason and decide what appropriate management or procedural steps remain available. Avoid treating refusal as proof of wrongdoing.


GOV.UK confirms that a mediator cannot force participants to accept a solution. Make sure everyone understands that decisions about an agreement remain with those taking part.


4. Who can facilitate impartially?


We recommend checking the proposed facilitator’s training, role and previous involvement. A manager who has already taken a strong position on the dispute may struggle to be seen as impartial.


Clarify the scope of the appointment and which information the facilitator will need. Keep responsibilities for any investigation or formal decision clear, rather than assuming one meeting will fulfil every purpose.


For employers, this is also a useful management training topic: knowing when to seek support is part of handling conflict responsibly.


5. What happens afterwards?


We suggest planning how any agreed practical steps would be implemented. Who needs to know about a change in handover arrangements or responsibilities? What can be shared, and how will that be agreed?


Acas explains that the mediator agrees with participants what information can be shared outside mediation. Respect those arrangements when planning follow-up. Avoid promising an outcome before discussions have taken place.


If no agreement is reached, assess the next step fairly. Managers still need to address the underlying work arrangements and any outstanding concerns through the appropriate route.


At The HFactor, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to complex employee relations and management training. We can help employers assess the situation and plan an appropriate response.


For a initial meeting, visit www.the-hfactor.com and use our enquiry form. Tell us what has happened, what has already been tried and what remains unresolved.


Sources checked 24 October 2026


Acas — Workplace mediation: purpose, suitability and confidentiality



GOV.UK — Mediation, conciliation and arbitration



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page