top of page

The companion at a disciplinary hearing: what managers need to understand

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 22
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

A manager has prepared the evidence, booked the meeting and sent the invitation. Then the worker arrives with a companion and the chair is unsure how much they can contribute.


An instruction that the companion must remain silent can create an avoidable problem before the evidence is discussed. We recommend giving managers a practical briefing on how the hearing will run, including the role of everyone attending.


Understand when the right applies


The Acas Code explains that workers have a statutory right to be accompanied, on a reasonable request, at disciplinary meetings that could lead to a formal warning or other disciplinary action, and at relevant appeal hearings.


The eligible categories are a fellow worker, an employed trade union official or a trade union representative certified by the union as competent to accompany them. Check your own procedure too. Acas also explains that reasonable adjustments for a disabled worker may involve allowing a different companion.


We recommend identifying the type of meeting before sending an invitation. An investigation meeting and a disciplinary hearing serve different purposes. The chair should be able to explain which stage the organisation has reached.


Know what the companion can do


Under the Code, a companion can present and summarise the worker’s case, respond to points and confer with the worker. The role does not give an automatic right to answer questions for them or prevent the employer explaining its case.


We suggest opening with a clear explanation of how questions and contributions will be handled. Invite the companion to flag when a short pause would help. This gives the chair a workable structure without treating participation as an interruption.


Prepare the hearing, not just the paperwork


Acas guidance says employees should receive the allegations, relevant evidence and possible outcomes in advance, with reasonable time to prepare. It also recommends allowing the companion time to prepare.


Our practical recommendation is to check the meeting pack from the recipient’s perspective. Are pages numbered? Do documents open? Are dates consistent? Can everyone locate the item being discussed?


A chair who spends the hearing searching for an attachment has less attention available for listening. These small preparation steps support a more focused discussion.


Rehearse the difficult moments


We recommend using short practice exercises in management training. Ask the chair to respond when the companion raises a new point, when the worker asks for a private conversation, or when someone says they have not received an important document.


The purpose is to develop judgement about when to explain, clarify, pause or seek advice. Managers also need to recognise where a procedural request needs assessment rather than an immediate refusal. Requests to rearrange a hearing, for example, need consideration of the applicable rules and circumstances.


Close with a clear next step


Leave time to check whether anything relevant remains unheard. Explain what will happen after the meeting and who will communicate the next step. Keep a clear record of points requiring follow-up.


At The HFactor, we support complex employee relations and provide practical management training, drawing on 85 years of combined HR experience.


If your managers need help preparing for a hearing or building their confidence, visit www.the-hfactor.com and complete our enquiry form for a initial meeting.


Sources checked 22 October 2026


Acas — Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures, particularly paragraphs 13–17



Acas — Step 4: The disciplinary hearing



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page