top of page

Who can open your HR files? A practical access audit for employers

Writer: Karen Lewis
Karen Lewis
Oct 25
3 min read

Updated: Oct 29

An organisation chart changes in a meeting. Access to the old team's HR folders may remain unchanged for months.


We recommend making information access part of the people change process. A manager should be able to find the records needed to do their job, while private information remains appropriately protected.


Start with responsibilities


The ICO's employment records guidance says access should be limited to authorised people acting within their authority, with managers seeing the information needed for their responsibilities. Health information also attracts additional protection as special category data.


We suggest beginning an audit with three questions: which responsibilities does this person hold, what information is necessary for those responsibilities, and who approves access? A job title on its own rarely provides the full answer.


Walk through one recent change


Choose a recent promotion, team move or departure. Trace what happened from the HR notification to the changes made in each system. Look for the person who requested the change, the person who completed it and the record showing it happened.


An internal move deserves attention because the individual may remain a trusted colleague while no longer needing the previous team's records. We recommend adding an access review to the manager handover, with IT involved where technical changes are needed.


Check the copies outside the HR system


A useful audit looks beyond the main personnel platform. Ask managers how they actually prepare for a meeting, send information to payroll or share interview notes. This can reveal exports and working copies that the formal process does not describe.


We recommend selecting one routine task and observing the steps with those responsible. An unexplained spreadsheet is easier to address when someone can explain why it exists and what work would otherwise be difficult. The aim is a workable process with clear ownership.


Include recruitment and sensitive casework


For recruitment, identify the people on each interview panel and review access once their involvement ends. Keep equality monitoring separate from selection material, with access reflecting the different purposes.


For complex employee relations, decide who needs case documents and how access changes when an investigator or decision maker finishes their role. Explain to managers where to request records rather than encouraging them to maintain their own unrestricted archive.


Check information flows during TUPE


TUPE can require specified employee information to be shared with a new employer. It does not remove data protection responsibilities or provide a blanket justification for sharing every document. The ICO distinguishes required employee liability information from additional information requested during due diligence.


We recommend agreeing the intended recipients, transfer method and responsibility for access before material is shared. Include the receiving organisation in that planning rather than treating the handover as complete when an email is sent.


Turn findings into owned actions


The ICO's security guidance requires measures appropriate to the risks, including protection against unauthorised access and processes to check effectiveness. We suggest recording each audit action with an owner, due date and confirmation of completion. Involve IT or data protection specialists where the findings require their expertise.


At The HFactor HR Consultancy, we bring 85 years of combined HR experience to HR audits, TUPE and practical management support. For a initial meeting about your HR processes, contact us through www.the-hfactor.com.


Sources checked 25 October 2026


ICO — Collecting and keeping employment records:



ICO — Using employment records:



ICO — A guide to data security:



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page